Community Engagement for Collective Impact: Lessons From Alaska

shaking hands
Forum for Youth Investment
Karen Pittman
October 14, 2014

People who run collective impact efforts say one of their toughest tasks is keeping community engagement going beyond the "summits" where everyone gets fired up. What does it mean to keep communities engaged in the mission that they've signed on for? Why is it so hard to do this well?

I mused on these questions in an earlier blog ("Putting Community Into Community Engagement"), promising to return with a story from a group that found a way to put community members at the head of its change efforts. My search took me as far from my comfort space (improving opportunities for urban, disadvantaged youth) as I could go: rural Alaska.

I didn't actually travel to Alaska -- only to Aspen, Colorado. That's where I met Brian McNitt, program officer for the Alaska Conservation Foundation and lead staff for its Sustainable Southeast Partnership. At the Collective Impact Funders Forum (hosted by the Aspen Institute and FSG) last spring, Brian told of how the foundation created a network of professional staff (called "catalysts") in the communities where it works. These catalysts keep the local work moving and keep the communities connected with each other and the foundation.

I interviewed Brian to find out more about how they made this work. Here are the six things I learned:

Define "community" the way the residents do. Southeastern Alaska is no more a community than Northern Kentucky (a region where the Forum works). Brian and the Foundation had to acknowledge that convening people from different geographically and sometimes culturally isolated communities to discuss how to address community problems was convenient for conveners, but did nothing to catalyze change locally. They decided to decentralize the effort and build capacity in 12 small communities.

Pick people, not organizations, to mobilize people. They waited to start organizing for change in a community until they found a resident "community catalyst" who had the passion, networks and skills needed to build momentum. In one community, the Foundation even stopped the work because it couldn't find an appropriate replacement for the original local catalyst.

Give the catalysts the right supports. Understanding the challenges and complexity of the work, they carefully created support scaffolding around these local leaders. First, they asked the community catalysts to help identify a local organization to host the local work. This organization then received a grant to hire the catalyst and support the effort.

Second, they hired regional catalysts with expertise in the each of their four resource issues (food security, renewable energy, sustainable economic development, natural resource management) to support the community catalysts. Third, they provide a rich array of online and face-to-face networking opportunities for both groups of catalysts.

Build the shared agenda from the bottom up. The Partnership has a central table. Several of the host organizations join Brian (the only Foundation staff person) on a Leadership Team that crafts and monitors progress toward a shared agenda. This agenda reflects the projects and priorities selected by advisory groups in each community. Brian noted, "We start with a person who has interest and connections, and work outward."

Believe in the tipping point approach. The Partnership works with seven of the 30 communities in Southeast Alaska, and hopes to expand to 12 within a few years. It does not think it needs to work directly in all 30. The Partnership is starting with the communities that are the most ready, hoping that deeply changing the norms in about one-third of the communities will eventually change norms across the region.

Stay true to the model. Brian was not only open but proud of the fact that the Foundation has gotten it wrong sometimes. It has replaced host organizations that weren't a good fit, usually because the host didn't embrace the collaborative spirit that is central to the initiative. Foundation staff have come close to wanting to speed things up by pressing through decisions or just doing the work themselves. They quickly realize (or are reminded of) the biggest lesson they have learned: "Unless we really embrace and support the idea of a community base -- people in the community, from the community, engaging others in the community -- and let that base tell us what's important, we won't get the level of buy-in necessary to move the agenda."

I asked Brian two questions that you're probably asking yourself: 1. Can you give me an example of change that has happened that you're sure would not have happened with a different approach? 2. This worked in rural Alaska, but do you think it has relevance for the rest of the country? His answers were not only yes, they were inspiring.

To see those answers and to learn more, read these excerpts from the interview.

Share this SparkAction Link: click here to shorten

Extraordinary, This particular net website page is truly exciting and delight to learn. I'm a colossal fan from the subjects said.
e liquid

October 11 at 02:28pm

we are a Hong Kong based professional language centre providing Mandarin, Cantonese, English, Korean, Japanese, Arabic and French courses.
learn english in hong kong

September 28 at 11:21am

The website about the art of joshua pellicer women's attraction. Dating for men
tao of badass pdf

September 28 at 06:25am

demandez votre carte grise en ligne en toute simplicité avec les services
carte grise en ligne

September 23 at 12:07pm

I am unable to read articles online very often, but I’m glad I did today.
govt jobs 2017

September 23 at 10:52am

I make sense of that one gains some new useful knowledge ordinary. Educational site incidentally.
mp3 free download

September 21 at 07:20am

airport transportation company in sanford fl
sanford airport transportation

September 20 at 02:32pm

It truly regards realize that this subject is being secured additionally on this site so cheers for setting aside opportunity to examine this!
darkest days how to survive an emp attack to the grid pdf

September 17 at 05:48am

Intriguing and stunning how your post is! It Is Useful and supportive for me That I like it in particular, and I am anticipating Hearing from your next..
inspirational quotes to read

September 16 at 07:36am

Goodness, cool post. I'd get a kick out of the chance to compose like this as well – requiring some serious energy and genuine diligent work to make an awesome article… however I put things off excessively and never appear to begin. Much appreciated however.

September 15 at 06:08pm

That is the phenomenal mentality,
look at this

September 14 at 04:16pm

We are offering the best SEO Services in New Zealand. Rank your website higher on search engines be on the first page of Google now.
seo services

September 10 at 04:42pm

The web is stalled with counterfeit online journals with no genuine message yet the post was fabulous and definitely justified even despite the read.Thank you for imparting this to me.

September 10 at 03:09pm

Hotel-24 is a comfortable, well-equipped hotel in a convenient location in Płock at ul. Borderline 54/1. Our property combines a warm, unique atmosphere with good style and attractive accommodation rates.
hotel 24 płock

September 7 at 09:13am

Phenomenal article. Exceptionally intriguing to peruse. I truly love to peruse such a pleasant article. Much appreciated! continue shaking.
Reuben Singh

September 3 at 05:33pm

truly cool and this is an incredible motivating article. Much thanks to you to such an extent. .

September 2 at 03:13pm

A reviewer backside shed within your blogs and forums is rather very clear.
Manifestation Millionaire

August 31 at 01:32pm

I simply need to tell you that I simply look at your site and I think that its extremely fascinating and educational.
moped insurance

August 27 at 05:20pm
August 27 at 04:11pm

دانلود قسمت 14 چهاردهم سریال عاشقانه با لینک مستقیم, دانلود رایگان سریال عاشقانه, دانلود سریال جدید عاشقانه ایرانی دانلود سریال عاشقانه با لینک مستقیم, دانلود فیلم های جدید و برتر, دانلود رایگان فیلم و سریال با لینک مستقیم
دانلود قسمت 14 عاشقانه

July 18 at 07:40am

I highly recommend you continue on the following superb deliver the results plus I actually look ahead to extra within your magnificent content.
NutraTrim TrimFx Review

July 14 at 09:01am

Did you ever want to react on webform submission using rules but couldn't find the proper event ?
obat mata minus herbal
Webform Rules makes it possible to catch webform submissions by rules and do whatever you'd like to do with it (meaning: do whatever rules let you do with it) ...

June 21 at 09:23pm

Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business.

April 16 at 02:19pm

On the wood is the famous Lebanese bakery in Sharjah serve all kinds of bread, pastries and sweets. Dial 600546008 for FOOD DELIVERY service in Sharjah. You can also come and enjoy the finest Lebanese sweets.
Lebanese bakery in sharjah

April 14 at 07:26am

Offering wide collection of men designer bags made from high quality materials. Our bags made in Italy and we ship it for free to you.
designer mens leather messenger bags

April 4 at 07:36am

Brilliant .i love it reading.
Bluetooth Speaker Promotional Item

March 29 at 10:44am

Hmm… I read blogs on a similar topic, but i never visited your blog. I added it to favorites and i’ll be your constant reader.
Moreno Valley seo

March 28 at 11:57am

The information you have posted is very useful. The sites you have referred was good. Thanks for sharing..
Creatif Designs

March 27 at 02:44pm

We can save you hundreds of dollars on new electric facial beds, manicure tables, pedicure chairs, led light therapy systems , nail salon equipment, massage tables, spa supplies, aromatherapy supplies, facial and massage therapy, aesthetic tables, facial steamer, a diamond microdermabrasion system, or even a crystal microdermabrasion machines.
Please take a few minutes of your time today and become a member to receive the best deals on salon and spa equipment and products; including private sale specials, exclusive coupons and other money saving deals from our wonderful selection.

March 27 at 08:32am

I truly enjoyed reading your post. we will bookmark your blog for future refernece. I want to encourage one to continue your Great post

March 26 at 04:04pm

Bosna Hersek Üniversiteleri türkiye temsilciliği Bosnada Eğitim Resmi Web Sitesi Study İn Bosnia Herzegovina
Bosna Hersek Üniversiteleri

March 26 at 11:20am

High Quality Follower, Likes, Views, Comments, Website Traffic from Real User at the HQlike online shop.
buy Comments

March 26 at 07:49am

Excellent information on your blog, thank you for taking the time to share with us.

March 24 at 12:00pm

Nice knowledge gaining article.
pregnancy massage NJ

March 17 at 11:08am

I love the way you write and share your niche! Very interesting and different! Keep it coming!
Traffic Trigger

March 17 at 09:08am

Agen Judi Online Bola, Taruhan Bola, Casino Online Dan Poker Online Terpercaya , Partner resmi Master Agen 805bet Yang Menyediakan Jasa Pembuatan akun betting Judi Online Terbaik, Aman Dan Terpercaya sejak 2011. Buktikan!!
agen judi

March 16 at 08:30am

The sites you have referred was good. Thanks for sharing..

March 15 at 02:34pm

In one place, experts get a quality checked and transparent overview of all Life Sciences jobs that we can find on the internet. BrightOwl is the place to be for Life Sciences experts looking for a job. We believe in the perfect mix of technology and a personal touch. A learning algorithm helps experts to filter out those jobs that best match their personal preferences and we help in the recruitment process with screenings and personal interviews.
laboratory jobs

March 14 at 03:51pm

I have read your blog it is very helpful for me. I want to say thanks to you. I have bookmark your site for future updates.
leased line costs

March 13 at 03:50pm

I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work.
Sell Your Annuities

March 13 at 01:38pm

Paper Writing Experts is a reputed and leading provider of custom academic papers and proofreading services. Our highly qualified writers can produce high quality academic essays and dissertations within short deadlines. We guarantee Plagiarism-free content and 100% confidentiality.
essay help online

March 13 at 09:55am

Je Trouwpak kopen bij Suits at Sea is een gezellig en leuk uitje voor de bruidegom met aanhang. Ze verkopen luxe Trouwpakken voor mannen, die je zelf tot in detail style'd. En met oog voor detail worden je Trouwpak op Maat gemaakt, topkwaliteit. En tevredenheid wordt gegarandeerd. Wil je ook je Trouwpak op maat laten maken? Check de site!
Trouwpak kopen

March 12 at 03:25pm

howdy, your websites are really good. I appreciate your work.

March 12 at 01:44pm

I am appreciating it very much! Looking forward to another great article.
here hair care and skin care tips website

March 11 at 04:14pm

Luxury timepieces, Rolex, Hublot, Omega, Cartier, Breitling, Ulysee Nardin, IWC, Chopard, Diamond watches.
shop diamond rings

March 11 at 02:04pm

Luxury timepieces, Rolex, Hublot, Omega, Cartier, Breitling, Ulysee Nardin, IWC, Chopard, Diamond watches.
shop diamond rings

March 11 at 02:02pm

Webmusic In Hindi Songs Bollywood latest Movies Songs Free Download in

March 11 at 10:22am

but this articles quality is much, much better. How you do this..
does male extra really work

March 9 at 04:03pm

Among the lots of comments on your articles. Thanks for sharing.

March 9 at 02:25pm

Thank you for this post. Thats all I are able to say. You most absolutely have built this blog website into something speciel
kou tea reviews

March 9 at 01:02pm


receive our updates

Back to:

Spark Tweets