Slum Living: When Access as Proxy for Quality Is Life-Threatening

Youth Today
Stephanie Krauss
March 30, 2016

The summer after my second year teaching, I traveled to Malawi — one of the poorest nations in east Africa — with an organization that trains and supports new teachers. In addition to the teacher training program, this group provides housing, education and feeding programs to children in city slums and rural villages.

At a feeding program outside of Lilongwe, the nation’s capital, we met many children, each of whom got a bowl of nshima, a doughy substance made from maize (white corn flour). I was told that some days, children received greens on the side. On special occasions, they got beans or meat.

I wondered about the efficacy of the feeding program. Access to some food is better than no food. Even so, nshima can fill bellies, but how well can it nourish brains and bodies on its own?

Years later, my husband and I met Dr. Mark Manary and his wife, Mardi, members of our church. Mark is a pediatrician and professor at Washington University in St. Louis who, together with Mardi (a pediatric nurse), co-founded Project Peanut Butter.

Mark and Mardi started Project Peanut Butter after living in Tanzania, another east African country. The Manarys were concerned by the awful recovery rates for children with severe malnutrition — just three or four out of every 10 children were surviving with standard treatment. After much study, he found Ready to Use Therapeutic Foods (RUTF).

RUTF is a vitamin- and mineral-rich peanut butter paste. It is easy to digest and hard to spoil. In 2004, the Manarys began working with the World Health Organization and Malawi nationals to use RUTF as a primary child nutrition treatment. The results were staggering. Recovery rates soared to 75 to 95 percent.

Today, Project Peanut Butter operates 20 mobile sites throughout Malawi, providing RUTF to children and their caretakers. Unlike most feeding programs, Project Peanut Butter empowers caretakers by training them on how to administer the peanut butter paste and sending them home with a personal supply.

Consider the difference. Two severely malnourished children are trying to survive in Malawi slums. Both access a feeding program. Because of this, they are better off than the child who is hungry but unable to access a feeding program. One of those children attends the program I visited. The other visits a Project Peanut Butter mobile site. The child who receives RUTF has a 75 to 95 percent chance of surviving. In spite of great intentions and high hopes, the other child is only half as likely to survive.

This pronounced example of access as proxy for quality showcases the dangers of allowing program availability to be as important as effectiveness. In the United States, this trap shows up in many different ways — the difference in after-school or summer programming in two urban neighborhoods, one affluent and one impoverished. Or, the difference in the quality of public schooling or health-care services on an American Indian reservation, versus its surrounding towns.

Too often we focus on improving access, stretching the number of people or places we can serve, without ensuring quality of those services. We report on the number of children fed, enrolled, educated or inoculated. We struggle to show how those children have been nourished and served, educated and medicated with the same level of care and quality as their peers from different communities.

Access is an easy proxy for quality because it feels good and right. And it is. As long as it includes the promise to save and improve the lives of children now served.

We can’t mistake the access to summer or any other child and youth programming as a proxy for quality. This summer, let’s ensure that kids not only have access to opportunities for learning, growth and nutrition — but that what we provide meets quality standards and changes lives for the better.

stephanie kraussStephanie Malia Krauss is a senior fellow at The Forum For Youth Investment, focusing on issues of youth readiness and competencybased education. She was previously president and chief executive officer of Shearwater Education Foundation.

This article originally appeared on Youth Today. It is reprinted here with permission. 

Share this SparkAction Link: click here to shorten

These are some extraordinary devices that i unquestionably use for SEO work. This is an awesome rundown to use later on.. italian shoes

July 3 at 05:32pm
July 3 at 08:00am

Exceptionally helpful data. Would like to see more posts soon!. italian shoes for women on sale

June 14 at 03:25pm

i am always looking for some free stuffs over the internet. there are also some companies which gives free samples.
extra long tee shirts for men

February 2 at 02:08am

Good website! I truly love how it is easy on my eyes it is. I am wondering how I might be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your RSS which may do the trick? Have a great day!
voyance telephone

February 1 at 02:39am

I admit, I have not been on this web page in a long time... however it was another joy to see It is such an important topic and ignored by so many, even professionals. professionals. I thank you to help making people more aware of possible issues.
diabetes tipo 2

January 25 at 02:11am

Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business.
Dentist Dubai

December 10 at 03:02pm

Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going.... I really enjoyed exploring your site. good resource... watches

October 15 at 02:39am

You know your projects stand out of the herd. There is something special about them. It seems to me all of them are really brilliant! satta matka

October 13 at 11:06am

I wondered about the efficacy of the feeding program. We must focus on improving access, stretching the number of people or places we can serve, without ensuring quality of those services. Thesis writing service provides top quality of papers for the students.

June 22 at 05:27am
May 22 at 09:25pm

The information you have posted is very useful. The sites you have referred was good. Thanks for sharing...
Distributor Baja Ringan Surabaya

April 19 at 11:22pm





April 15 at 02:24am
April 11 at 07:18am
April 7 at 01:03am

Books and online articles are my great inspiration for always. So, spend time to read some books and improve my knowledge. It is really wonderful post. The topic you have chosen here to discuss has a great social relevancy in the present situation. I was a writer at college paper writing service before and I did many write up like this there for students.

April 4 at 05:00am


receive our updates

Spark Tweets