Why School Suspensions Don’t Work

Youth Today
Stephanie Malia Krauss
January 26, 2016

I never had a student change his behavior for the better because he was suspended. Most of the time students returned and reoffended. Time away from school seemed to exacerbate problems, not fix them.

As a public school leader, I was in charge of major disciplinary actions — suspensions and expulsions. My school was for older, disconnected youth, some with violent and criminal backgrounds. We had to suspend students for all types of reasons: theft, fighting, threatening, bringing a weapon to school.

Even in a school run by social workers, our commitment to helping students was handicapped by some pretty arbitrary discipline rules. Our school board set and approved disciplinary policies, which were developed in partnership with our school leadership team, under the advisement of our lawyer. We all understood there were precedents to follow.

When we started, our discipline committee pored over policies from every area school district. Our lawyers told us to stay consistent with others. It would protect our school. I got it: Can you imagine what a judge and jury would think if we were a zero-suspension school, and a student with a history of violent behavior injured or killed a student or staff member?

So we set policies that mirrored those who had gone before us. Depending on the infraction, students could be suspended for one to three days or 11 to 180 days. If suspended, a student was given a bus ticket and a performance improvement plan. Requirements for her return were put in place. I am glad to say, those requirements often included supports and therapeutic interventions. But while a student was gone, she was provided with very little beyond schoolwork.

Thinking back, I know we set students up to fail. We followed precedents and protocol. We understood suspensions did not work, but when someone did something really risky or scary, removal was more appealing than restoration.

As a system, we induced a cycle of problem behavior. Students would act out, get sent home, be suspended, then return to school some number of days later. Now behind in their work, and embarrassed (or proud) of their absence, they would be more easily agitated and more likely to act out again. Quite a few of our students would spend their time away engaging in the same kinds of behavior, which could include running the streets, staying up late, drinking or doing drugs. They would come back in rough shape — hungry, hungover and tired.

As a leader, I allowed our school to use time as proxy for progress when it came to all major disciplinary situations. Some random number of days, first decided by some school district somewhere, was supposed to resolve whatever caused the suspension in the first place.

Time is not a cure-all for a young person’s problem behavior. Suspensions are easy to administer, monitor and track. Time-based policies are clean and can be uniform across settings and systems. A 10-day suspension looks the same and happens for the same reasons at my school and yours. We know when three or five or 10 days is up. We know when we should expect an instant change in behavior.

The problem is, it does not work. In the case of our school-based discipline, time was a poor proxy for progress, because students simply did not progress toward anything beneficial during their time away. And typically, the more time away the worse the results.

Time plays proxy for progress in many ways across youth systems. Juvenile judges issue timebased sentences: a certain number of days in a detention center or hours of community service. Educators follow seat-time credentialing requirements: a certain number of minutes of instruction to earn a unit of credit. Prevention programs set limits on the number of days or weeks a young person can be in a substance abuse treatment facility. Shelters and transitional living programs, often tied to public dollars, max out after a few weeks or months.

We all need to thoughtfully examine the efficacy of the time-based measures our youth systems rely on. Ask yourself, when and how does this measure lead a young person to move ahead, improve, grow and develop? Is there another way? A better way?

Knowing what I know now, I would have done more, much more, to find alternatives to suspension. I would have demanded our discipline practices kept all youth — including those who got in trouble — in the center.

It is time to set new precedents, to level the scales and bring progress-based measures up to the same level as our time-based ones. Each of us must come up with reasonable and scalable alternatives. If not, we will continue to have many young people biding their time — in school, out of school, in programs, out of programs — waiting to progress, waiting to finish. But in the wait, we will lose them.


stephanie kraussStephanie Malia Krauss is a senior fellow at The Forum For Youth Investment, focusing on issues of youth readiness and competencybased education. She was previously president and chief executive officer of Shearwater Education Foundation.

This article originally appeared on Youth Today. It is reprinted here with permission. 

Share this SparkAction Link: click here to shorten
copy http://sparkaction.org/content/why-school-suspensions-dont-work
181 Comments
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
August 18 at 03:07am
August 12 at 03:24am

Shared it Obat Gatal Jamur di Kemaluan battle Obat Nyeri Tumit can be useful for many people Obat Ambeien Thanks...

August 11 at 04:04am
August 5 at 02:06am

Visit Agen Resmi QnC Jelly Gamat Jakarta Selatan Thank you so much...

August 4 at 02:07am

Sharing it's Obat Penghancur Batu Ginjal thinking Obat Hepatitis B know G-Sea Jelly Gamat Emas Thanks you...

August 3 at 04:24am
August 2 at 02:20am

Visit this Obat kaki bengkak akibat asam urat funny Obat luka tergores Thank you so much...

July 24 at 03:35am

Visit Obat Limpa Bengkak everything Obat Sakit Leher dan Pundak Thank you...

July 21 at 03:45am

Sharing nih Obat Infeksi Telinga sleep Obat Borok Thank you so much...

July 20 at 04:58am

Good afternoon Obat Luka Robek Thanks ...

July 18 at 12:37am

Still Obat Asam Lambung Kambuh Thanks...

July 15 at 12:56am
July 13 at 12:12am

Talking Obat benjolan di belakang telinga Thank you...

July 11 at 11:26pm
July 11 at 11:25pm
July 6 at 12:47am

Stay Obat kencing manis delicious

July 6 at 12:47am
July 4 at 12:10am

Visit Obat Benjolan Wasir Sharing Obat Sakit Maag Mendadak Thank you very much ...

June 22 at 12:38am

Selamat pagi Obat Kuku Cantengan interesting Obat Kista Coklat much Obat Penyakit Kuning Thanks...

June 20 at 12:34am
June 16 at 03:38am
June 15 at 02:51am
June 14 at 03:16am
June 14 at 03:15am
June 13 at 03:21am
June 9 at 02:38am
May 30 at 01:57am

I know Obat Penyakit Gula see Obat Alergi Rhinitis Thank you...

May 29 at 01:43am
May 24 at 12:48am
May 19 at 02:42am
May 17 at 02:01am
May 17 at 02:00am

Hopefully this website Obat Sakit Tumit like Obat Benjolan Karena Asam Urat small Obat Tulang Dan Sendi Linu still Obat Paru-Paru Basah maybe Obat Kencing Batu can be useful for many people ... amazing !!

May 9 at 12:24am
May 3 at 11:31pm

The things are very clear in your website for giving us right information at right time thanks for share with us.
paypal money adder

May 3 at 07:21pm
April 18 at 03:49am

Visit Obat Asam Urat Tinggi reading Obat Luka Lambung extraordinary !!

April 18 at 03:48am

Talk Obat Mata Rabun Senja Thank you very much ...

April 11 at 10:57pm
April 6 at 11:24pm

View website is really interesting and nice, amazing !! Obat Benjolan di Kelopak Mata

April 6 at 03:48am

Visits in our day, permission listen share insights on this website, Thank you very much Obat Nodul Tiroid and comment on Obat Sesak Nafas

April 6 at 02:19am

haring Obat GERD think Obat Kurap Thank you ...

April 5 at 03:24am

I really found this to much informatics. It is what i was searching for.I would like to suggest you that please keep sharing such type of info.Thanks obat ambeien

April 5 at 12:01am

I really found this to much informatics. It is what i was searching for.I would like to suggest you that please keep sharing such type of info.Thanks obat ambeien

April 5 at 12:01am

I am very happy to be able to visit this website, Thank you very much Obat Penurun SGOT Dan SGPT and Obat Penebalan Otot Jantung TOP !!

April 4 at 03:24am

connect

receive our updates

Spark Tweets